Top 10 Direct Mail Companies For Real Estate Investors In 2024

Who’s the best direct mail company for real estate investors? Well that’s the question we try to answer here today.

There are a ton of options out there in the marketplace. Some specialize in yellow letter marketing, others focus on postcard marketing primarily, and then some do handwritten direct mail only. 

Check out the Leaderboard below, see all the REI direct mail options, vote up your favorite mail service, and add one to the list if we’ve missed one.

For years, Yellow Letters have been at the forefront of direct marketing for Real Estate Investors and Realtors. Industry leaders swear by it's performance and have built incredible businesses off the back of the Yellow Letter. If you're looking for the most effective direct marketing method with the highest response rate, then the Yellow Letter is the way to go!

We know, we know. There are a lot of Yellow Letter direct marketing companies out there and you're probably wondering what makes us so much better than all of them.

Well, let's start off with the basics…

  • First of all, we are the very best at producing the most authentic and highest quality Yellow Letters! We're the best in the business, so why choose anyone else?  We offer the best quality Yellow Letter at the lowest possible price!
  • Next, we use real, genuine yellow notepad paper which, as you well know, is much thinner than the cheap, knock-off paper our competitors use which only saves them money and makes your Yellow Letters literally look and feel more like an advertisement than a personal letter handwritten specifically for the seller. Kind of defeats the purpose of the Yellow Letter personal touch, right?
  • Lastly, our Yellow Letters are printed in custom designed real handwritten fonts. When we say "real", we mean REAL! Choose from a selection of our favorite, most effective custom designed handwritten fonts or, maybe you prefer your own or a family member's or friend's handwriting. Simply complete our font design template, send it to us, and we'll produce your very own custom font for all your current and future Yellow Letter (or any other direct mail for that matter) marketing pieces whether you shop with us again or not!

Look, we know you could buy Yellow Letters for your Real Estate investing marketing from anyone and, surely, there are plenty out there that have fancy design-your-own letter software systems and a million templates to choose from, but let's be straight here. You know your Real Estate investment business better than anyone. When it comes to marketing for motivated sellers, we offer Real Estate Investors and Realtors the one thing they truly want: the most authentic and effective direct marketing options at the cheapest possible price!

People can tell the difference between a handwritten card and a “handwritten” font that’s been printed on a card.

We ran tests underground for 3 years in some of the most competitive markets and industries in the US.

Letters written with actual pens dominate the competition.

Eye-catching, jaw-dropping postcard drip campaign for your list.

What did we learn?

  1. People can smell a scam.
  2. “Handwritten” Fonts do not produce the same effect.
  3. An actual handwritten letter with a real pen invokes personal trust with a client before you even speak with them.

What happens when a distressed seller feels trust? They are more likely to give you a call! We have seen consistent average response rates of 1 to 1.5% in all markets (even in the most competitive markets in the country).

But don’t just take our word for it. Hear it from our clients who have experienced direct growth spikes from using Ballpoint.

Fast, Affordable Direct To Seller Marketing

Tired of real estate marketing campaigns that don't get you results? So are we.

We are the most competitive direct mail company; we can save your budget and your sanity. We deliver a fast campaign turn around that gets your phone ringing.

Real Estate Investors and Mortgage Brokers have specific marketing needs, and we help you meet them. From handwritten to professional, from postcards to mailing lists, we can get you what you need – fast.

We Make Direct Mail Easy & Efficient

Our process is simple, quick, and priced so it won't break the bank.

REIPrintMail is THE #1 Direct Marketing Solution of choice for the REI community. Why?

The most obvious reason is our Direct Marketing Coaches, which each of our clients receives. Our coaches do not charge one single penny for their advice – we do it because we believe that if we help our clients get deals, we will build a long-lasting partnership.

So, what do you get from a partnership with one of our DMC’s?

  • A personal partner in the business who is committed to helping you get more deals!
  • An expert in the REI industry (they know exactly what you need to do to increase your deal flow)
  • Actual investors themselves
  • National intel as to what’s working and what’s not
  • Expert list preparation including:
  • o Motivated sellers
  • o Vacant property
  • o Distressed sellers
  • o Motivated buyers
  • o Best in class probate
  • o Skip tracing
  • o And a bunch more

As a client, you have access to the largest library of direct marketing mailers in the industry, but we don’t stop there. Every month we add 6 new templates to ensure the highest rate of returns and most deals per campaign. Our reverse texting solution is a proprietary texting tool and you can only find it at REIPrintMail.

If you’re not yet convinced that we should be your partner, take a look at our Google reviews and hear from some of our clients.

If you’re intrigued and would like to learn more, schedule a call with one of DMC’s. It could change your life!!

Optimize your Direct to Seller Marketing with products and strategies that really work!

Generate higher response rates and improve ROI with market-tested direct mail & digital marketing tools

Autopen, hand-written letters for real estate investors that set you apart.

Trusted by over 12,784 Investors and Realtors for their direct mail needs. With over 500 Real Estate Templates that create results to choose from, more added daily with your success in mind. We sell Yellow Letters and Postcards for Real Estate Investors, Realtors, Agents, and Brokers. We have Probate Letters, Inherited Letters, Vacant Letters, Multi-Family Letters, Just Sold Postcards and I Buy Houses Direct Mail. We have everything for the Real Estate Professional. If You Need a Custom Letter we can do that too.

Marketing that works, created by a Broker-Investor with Your Success in Mind!

Everybody wants to get the best deal possible. That’s why we offer you a price match guarantee and provide 100% customer satisfaction. We do what it takes to earn and keep your business!

Everest Direct Mail Marketing introduces…

Yellow Letters and Handwritten Direct Mail

We use real yellow lined and white lined memo paper, with blue lines and red margins, just like the notepad paper you’ll find in the stores. It’s as if you ripped a page right out of a memo pad, wrote a real letter, and sent it personally to the client yourself!

The lightweight look and feel is sure to catch potential clients’ attention because of the authenticity of the paper quality. We never cut corners by simply printing lines on regular copy paper or using fake memo paper. 

These yellow letters can be stuffed into a multitude of different colored envelopes, also boasting legitimate handwritten or chaos font for the return and recipient addresses, optimizing the chance for open rates and a high return on your investment. 

The yellow letters mail program is customized to fit each clients’ needs and make every penny count. There are no limiting letter templates that bind you to just two or three content options – meaning no two mailers are alike and your letters are exclusive and one of a kind. 

You have free reign on what you put in your letter, including the type of handwritten font, the color and size of the font, and whatever content and merge fields you’d like to include. This way, you can be sure your yellow letter is unique and will stand out from any other yellow letter mailer. 


We make it easy to plan and launch effective REI Direct Mailing Campaigns

Our specialized services for Real Estate Investors are a great marketing strategy for private real estate investment, commercial property real estate investing, or real estate wholesaling. We offer tons of different postcard and letter designs to implement direct mail real estate investor marketing plans to generate investment opportunities. Each real estate investor marketing design can be used as-is or edited to your desired look and need.

We also recently launched Google® Street View postcards and letters!

Industry's preffered direct mail method. Guaranteed to have great results at the lowest cost!

Create an immediate impact on the property owner by displaying a picture of their property on the postcard.

Letters to property owners are surely to get their attention giving it a personal and friendly touch.

Create an immediate impact on the property owner by displaying a picture of their property on the letter.

Genius Real Estate Investors Postcard Templates

Our real estate investors postcard templates will generate leads and return on investment in your marketing strategy — specifically when mailed consistently! Our designs include We Buy Houses Cash Postcards, Yellow Letter Postcards, and many other postcards for real estate investors. Want a fully custom real estate wholesaling postcard? No problem! We can design from scratch a postcard for your business at a fraction of the cost of other trained graphic designers. Plus, you can get a FREE sample pack of our real estate investors postcard templates by just entering your email below. We’ll mail this sample pack straight to you, again 100% FREE!

Handwritten Yellow Letters for Real Estate Investors & Brokers

If you’re in the business of buying and selling homes, yellow letters is one of the the most effective forms of connecting with buyers.

Our yellow letters are handwritten by real people and mailed in hand addressed, colored envelopes with live, hand-affixed stamps. This results in a highly personalized campaign that gets results.

99% Open Rate

Most promotional mail your prospect is used to receiving is either sent in boring window envelopes or glossy envelopes covered in flashy graphics. Yellow letter mail stands out because it´s mailed in hand addressed envelopes. So your letter looks like it came from a friend, not a faceless company.

Instantly Stands Out

Once your prospect opens the letter, your message instantly stands out because it looks like it was personally written just for the them. Our yellow letters are written on yellow legal pad paper with real handwriting and colored ink.

Customize a template online.

Start with one of our 36 proven real estate investor postcard templates and then select your color theme. Next you’ll be able to edit the text on the card, upload your logo and headshot and more. With just a few clicks you will have a gorgeous postcard design that is ready to print and mail!

Choose who you want to target.

You can upload your own list of prospects that you want to target, or choose from a variety of options to target new prospects. Choose the geographical area you want to target by zip code or radius around an address and then choose from 30+ demographic selections including home value, presence of children, age, income and more.

Click send!

Once you’ve selected your targeted prospects and customized your template, you now just click send and your postcards are printed and mailed within 48 hours!

Generate More Listings With Our Unique Property And Home Investor Direct Mail Solutions!

Finding quality investment properties can be very difficult and competitve. One of the most commonly used real estate solutions to reach potential sellers are investor direct mailers. Property investor direct mail continues to be the most successful form of real estate marketing because of its ability to reach qualified leads at a low cost! Home investor direct mail include postcards, snap packs, letters and envelopes, brochures, flyers, and more!

The Addressers has proudly served local and national property investors and home investors for over 40 years! We know how competitive the real estate industry can be. Thankfully, our market knowledge and in-house equipment allows us to offer unique investor marketing solutions that will get you ahead of the competition. Don’t send out generic postcards, but surprise your prospects with Google street view mailers, hand addressed mailers, pen addressed mailers, post-it note mailers, and more!

Your marketing will stand out with our broad selection of letters for every campaign and style. Available in Truly Handwritten™ or printed envelopes and fully customizable.

Want to be added to this list? Click here to bring up our submission form. We will be in touch shortly with feedback.

Spread the love:

Picture of Jason Moss
Jason Moss

Request a FREE SEO Audit

#1: Submit your website

#2: We’ll perform a comprehensive audit of your website and your overall brand visibility.

#3: We’ll followup to discuss our findings and present a clear roadmap on how to improve your ranking.

FREE SEO Audit  

Learn what your growth opportunities are.